LateNightCable Geschrieben 18. Oktober 2003 This is an excerpt of an interveiw with Gerhard Richter, Director of Development at BMW M. It's from April 2000, but it is still valid in terms of the things it discusses. Here, Gerhard Richter explains the delicate science that is BMW engineering, in particular, their engines. Anyone who does not understand why BMW doesn't use forced induction should read this to gain a better understanding, of BMW's philosophy of engine design. - LateNightCable ........................ Every motorist can imagine what high engine speeds are all about. But what is the nature of a concept based on such high engine speeds form the outset? Richter : We see this concept as the most intelligent way to deliver high power and performance from a compact engine. We are well aquainted with high speed engines particularly in motorsport. In a modern Formula 1 engine, for example, the crankshaft rotates up to 18,000 times a minute, each of the 10 pistons covering about 25 metres of piston travel every second! We need such extreme performance in order to provide maximum thrust and torque in conjunction with the appropriate transmission. It is also the principle we apply to our M high engine speed concept. By comparison, what engine speed is the new power unit of the M3 able to acheive? Richter : The straight-six power unit in the BMW M3, which is an all-new engine from the ground up, revs at a speed of up to 8,000 rpm, that is a speed no comparable production engine anywhere in the world is able to acheive. Until just a few years ago, only racing cars came in this catagory, reaching this kind of engine speed. You were talking about thrust and torque - what does that mean in practice? Richter : Ultimately, it means the power that accelerates a car. Following simple laws of physics, this thrust or torque is always proportional to the car's actual acceleration. In other words: The higher the speed of the engine - naturally always in combination with the best possible transmission ratio - the greater the torque and thrust you get when accelerating. This is the feeling of acceleration the driver will experiance at the wheel. This is where he ultimately feels the power on the wheels of his car, and not say, the - more hypothetical - horsepower claimed in the sales brochure. Does that mean that the engine power of a car claimed on paper doesn't say that much about it's actual performance? Richter : Right. You must realize that there are various ways to develop high power. One manufacturer prefers engines with lots of cubic capacity, but running at low engine speeds. ( Mercedes-Benz, hint hint. ) The disadvantage of such a power unit is that it takes up a lot of space, weighs a lot more, and normally consumes a lot of fuel. Another manufacturer by contrast, prefers compact engines revving at higher speed - which is precisely the approach we take with BMW M. So our objectives are to keep the engine reletively small and compact, to use less space and material, and, in particular, to keep fuel consumption to a reasonable level. All this, we believe, is crucial to the future of a reall sporting and dynamic car. How important is the torque of an engine in this context? ( high performance ) Richter : In principle, high torque means a lot of thrust and good acceleration. But the torque alone does not give you sporting performance on the road. Rather, you once again need engine speed and a quick response from the engine. To give you a comparison, a tractor on a farm powered by a diesel engine may develop up to 720 Newton metres or 530 lb-ft of torque - but with the engine revving at a mere 1,400 rpm, that tractor will obviously not accelerate very quickly. The M3, on the other hand , has only about half as much torque, ut reaches it's peak torque level at 4,900 rpm and accelerates to 100km/h in 5.2 seconds. And a Formula 1 racing car with more or less the same torque as our M Car accelerates even faster, because it reaches it's peak torque at an almost unbelievable 13,500 rpm. So ultimately, it's the ideal interaction of the transmission ratios and high engine speed that ensures superior performance on the road? Richter : Exactly. The big advantage of this high engine speed concept, is that it provides maximum performance on the road, even with a relatively small engine as well as compact axle and drive units. And a point we should not forget is that large engines consume a lot of fuel, due to the proportional connection between fuel consumtion and engine size : Generally, a large V8 engine will consume more fuel than an equally powerful, but more compact straight-six. And last but not least, there is the technical challenge presented by our concept, which really motivates every engine designer and engine builder. What exactly is that challenge? Richter : Implementing the high engine speed philosophy in an engine in practice is by all means a demanding job. Not everybody is able to do this - if it were easy, every manufacturer would apply this concept. Can you explain that in greater detail? Richter : Well, the physical loads acting on our M3 power unit are quite comparable to the loads you will measure in a Formula 1 engine, even though the level is somewhat different. One factor you will find in both cases, however, is the significant demand made of special materials, since the specific loads we have are roughly the same as in Formula 1. The big differecs, of course, is that a Formula 1 racing car has to last one race, whereas a BMW M engine must last for the entire life cycle of the car. How do you reach this goal? Richter : There are three absolutely essential " ingredients " : First, excellent engineers with good ideas; second, experiance in the use of high-tech materials; third and in particular, the availability of a very special, high-performance electronic control unit. Just consider that applying our demanding concept, we have to monitor, calculate and transmit millions of data with each revolution of the crankshaft. Precisely this is why we have developed a special control unit for this purpose at BMW M - there's nothing else like it anywhere in the market. Doesn't experiance from the development of Formula 1 engines at BMW go into every M engine? Richter : Yes, there is of course a fundamental excchange of experiance and know-how, even though the two projects - Formula 1 and the M3 - are entirely different in charicter. But one factor shared by both projects and technologies is that, at the end of the day, only the team with the highest engine speed can really beat the competition!